Area Targets: A Tango’s Dream

Area Targets: A Tango’s Dream

“They couldn’t hit an elephant at this dist–“

–Last words of Union General John Sedgwick, 09 May 1864

Question: How far away can you hit something with your rifle?

One answer might be, “How big is it?”

A single person or small object such as a narrow window is called a point target.

A group of people or an enemy camp is an area target.

 

Point Targets

Just about every Marine with a rifle can hit a motionless, man-sized target on a shooting range at, say, 450 meters, even without a scope.

Key word, “motionless.”

Troops in contact are not likely to be standing motionless like an E-series “green Earnie” target on a firing range. As the late, great Bill Dreeland, US Customs and Gunsite firearms instructor told us,

“If you are in a gunfight and you are standing in one place, it’s possible you may be doing something wrong.”

But the farther away the enemy, is, the more secure we feel we are, the more likely we are to be just standing or sitting around.

One night when my friend Max was in Iraq, a sentry was on duty in a sandbagged LP / OP (listening post / observation post) in the wider tower on the left in this photo of the Ottoman fortress of Tal’Afar.

The eastern wall of Tal’Afar castle. Image from The Castle of Tal’Afar, Lost Symbol of Hope and Redemption, by Chad Pillai

He must’ve felt fairly secure, behind the ramparts and sandbagged walls of that LP / OP.

That was not long after Revenge of the Sith came out. Perhaps he was remembering Obi-Wan’s words:

“It’s over, Anakin. I have the high ground.”

That sentry certainly had the high ground up there on that eastern wall. Besides, the “bad” part of town was more than a quarter of a mile away, on the other side of a wadi, and the gaps in the crenelated ramparts, augmented by sand bags, were no more than half a meter wide.

He felt so safe, he lit up a cigarette.

An insurgent sniper with a PSL rifle shot him through a gap in the rampart, from an estimated distance of 250 – 300 meters.

Romanian PSL, quasi-clone of the Russian SVD Dragunov (there are a few differences in the operating system). The scope isn’t bent in front; that’s a telescoping sleeve to shade the front glass, reducing reflection which could give the operator’s position away to the other side.

It’s true: smoking is bad for your health. Especially at night, when some of the bad guys have magnified optics on their rifles.

 

Effective Range

When the ordnance types do the statistical analyses to arrive at an effective range for any given weapons system, they’re talking about the distance at which the average soldier can hit a target, anywhere on the target, with more than half of his or her shots.

On paper, this so-called “average” soldier can hit an area target at 800 meters with an M16A2, and at 600 meters with an M4.

For example, one might shoot at an enemy artillery piece or mortar section 600 meters away, not to hit any particular cannon cocker (point target), but rather to force the enemy gun bunnies there (the entire group constituting an area target) to seek cover.

If you actually hit one of them, that would be a bonus, but it is not to be expected, nor really even necessary. As long as they are hiding from your harassing fire, and not manning their weapons, they and their cannon or mortar are out of the fight.

Which is all well and good, if you’re in the infantry or Marines. What does it have to do with your day-to-day life here in the ‘States?

 

Case Studies of Attacks on US Area Targets

Jonesboro, Arkansas

On 24 Mar 1998, two junior high students attacked the Westside Middle School in Jonesboro, AR. One pulled a fire alarm. The other was waiting on a nearby hillside to ambush them as they evacuated the school. The alarm-puller ran up there and joined him.

Students and educators evacuating the school on the right were shot from the wooded hillside to the left of this image. Four students and a teacher (Shannon Wright) were killed, and 10 others wounded, about where I was standing when I took this photo on 09 Oct 2022. Each of the students were point targets; the group of students was an area target.

The USA Today said that the shooter(s) were “about 100 yards away,” but the distance to the wooded high ground did not seem quite that far when I walked that terrain in October 2022.

Seven of their weapons were handguns; most people have difficulty hitting a motionless target with a handgun past 25 yards. They had three rifles: a Remington 742, a Universal M1 Carbine clone, and a Ruger .44 mag. Either of those rifles is quite capable of hitting point targets at less than a hundred yards–if the operator knows what s/he is doing. 

They may have targeted individuals (two in the crowd were ex-girlfriends), but it’s more likely they just shot into the group of 87 students and 9 teachers. The killers fired 30 rounds into the crowd, hitting 15 people.

Some were able to seek shelter from the killers in the gym.

View from the hillside about where the Jonesboro murderers waited in ambush. Gymnasium is behind the trees. The building on the left was under construction at the time of the attack. The walled area between the trees and the gym is a memorial garden placed there after the attack.

The Jonesboro pair may have been inspired by a sniping attack in Stamps, Arkansas the previous December (15 Dec 1997). A wannabe sniper shot a pair of students in the Stamps High School parking lot from a forested area nearby. The two Stamps HS victims were standing and talking, and constituted a pair of point targets, rather than an area target.

 

Las Vegas, Nevada

On 01 Oct 2017, an active shooter attacked the Route 91 Harvest Festival in Las Vegas, NV. It was the worst active shooting in US history.

It also lasted much longer. The people in the parking lot were under fire for 10 minutes. Most of the killing in a “typical” active shooter incident is over in three minutes, although some dying happens after that.

I took this photo in the 15-acre parking lot where the country music festival took place. The mass murderer was in a corner suite on the right side of the Mandalay Bay hotel. He shot through a broken window from an elevated position on the 32nd floor (he actually broke two windows, but the breeze blowing through between them slammed the door between the adjacent suites he was renting, locking him out of one).

Some of his victims were outside the fence, almost directly in line with the bad guy’s line of fire, on the west side of the parking lot, along Las Vegas Boulevard.

Image from archives.cedarcityutah.com

We call that being “in enfilade,” when the long axis of a group of people more or less lines up with the shooter’s guns. As opposed to “defilade,” where we are on the reverse slope of a hill or behind a bullet resistant wall or otherwise out of a killer’s direct line of fire. 

But the people listening to the concert from outside the fence could at least run away. It’s very difficult for even trained marksmen with optics to hit a target moving at a sprint perpendicular to them.

The vast majority of the killer’s victims were hemmed in INSIDE the fence, and could not get away.

It would be too complimentary to call that bozo in the Mandalay Bay a “sniper.” A sniper is a marksman. Although the hotel was about 450 meters from the parking lot, the thousands of people within the perimeter fence provided an area target. I doubt he had the skill to hit any specific person he might have aimed at. Instead, all his victims were hit by bullets addressed “to whom it may concern.” He just poured bullets into the (literally) captive audience, and was bound to hit someone.

 

“The Shot” at Adobe Walls, Texas

Grave marker for Billy Dixon at Adobe Walls, Texas

One of the most famous “precision” rifle shots in American history was actually aimed at an area target. In 1874, at the second battle of Adobe Walls in the northern panhandle of Texas, Quanah Parker and other Native American leaders were conferring on a hill about 3/4 of a mile away from the Adobe Walls trading post when a buffalo hunter named Billy Dixon (or one of his companions) knocked one of them off his horse.

Bluffs along the north edge of the Canadian River riparian area, east of the buffalo hunters’ trading post. Most versions of the story place a group of about 15 warriors atop the bluff to the left. Dixon and the other buffalo hunters, most of whom were, as an occupational requirement, good shots, were not far from where I took this photo.

Dixon and the other hunters were accustomed to murdering bison at considerable distance, and the Sharps buffalo guns they used were quite capable of hitting at stationary point targets at 1000 meters or more. Seeing and identifying a single individual at that distance without modern binoculars or a spotting scope would be another matter. Several Plains Indians were hit at considerable distances during the battle, and Dixon may not even have been the one who made “the” shot.

Although the feat is legendary, Dixon said he was just shooting at the entire group, and that he was lucky to have hit any of them.

Hills to the west of the trading post. The area target Dixon (and other hunters) shot at may have been atop one of those. Monument on the left was placed in honor of the Cheyenne and Comanche (and Arapahoe and Kiowa) braves who fell during the three-day battle. A close up of it appears at the top of this article.

Not so lucky was To-hah-kah, the brave who (in some versions of the story) was hit by “the shot.” Some accounts say he was killed; others that the lead .50 projectile’s velocity was so spent after traveling that distance (accounts vary in range from 800 to 1400+ meters) that it merely stunned him. When To-hah-kah went down, the other warriors on the hill immediately scattered (infantry types call that combat dispersion), but they returned shortly after that to rescue him (or recover his body, depending on which version you choose to believe).

If this subject fascinates you, you should get a life. Or, you can read more in 

  • James L. Haley’s The Buffalo War: The History of the Red River Indian Uprising of 1874, or
  • T. Lindsay Baker’s and Billy R. Harrison’s Adobe Walls: The History and Archaeology of the 1874 Trading Post

 

Above Ground Infrastructure = Area Targets

Fuel Tanks

The Route 91 Harvest Festival murderer also took several pot shots at a fuel tank at McCarran International Airport. The tank was about 600 meters away from his hide in the Mandalay Bay. His intent was apparently to cause a conflagration, either simply to enjoy the destruction or to lure firefighters into the kill zone of his ambush. Fortunately, jet fuel is mostly kerosene and not likely to be set ablaze with rifle fire; he did not succeed at causing a conflagration.

A pump at a gas station would be a point target; a gigantic fuel storage tank (or group of such tanks) for an airport is an area target.

Transformers and Other Electrical

One vulnerability that our nation has had for years, but has become more recognized and more significant recently (the farther we get from a day when most people could live without electricity for a few days), is our power grid.

 

Recent craven attacks have demonstrated that even a few well placed rifle shots can have a massive, cascading effect on our power grid.

Smaller (cylindrical) transformers are point targets; larger, rectangular transformers or entire electrical substations might constitute an area target.

Pipelines

Nordstreams 1 and 2 might have taken underwater demolition teams or depth charges to destroy, but any bozo with a rifle can punch holes in an above ground pipeline.

 

What Can be Done?

In the case of critical infrastructure, such as electrical substations and water wells, we can surround them with high, bullet-resistant walls or dirt berms that will at least protect them from projectiles launched from the same level.

In the service, we called that a revetment.

USAF uses the fence to limit intruder access. The dirt berm and storage box revetments are to protect (at least the bottoms of) these mothballed aircraft from street level gunfire. The berm is taller than it looks; this photo was taken from atop a GMC truck.

This electrical substation is protected from drive-bys.

Wells and storage systems for drinking water are vulnerable to sabotage, introduction of poisons or biohazards, and of course sniping or drive-by shooting. This partially revetted well has some protection against intruders as well as bullets. The addition of barbed wire on top of the wall would be better. Since vehicles need access, not much can be done about bullets penetrating the gate.

 

Movement

As individuals, we can make MOVEMENT our default response to incoming fire.

Movement is problematic if we are hemmed in by walls and furniture–which is most of the time. As a general rule, running directly away only gets us shot in the back.

Educators in an active violence class seeing from the killer’s perspective how ineffective running away is, when the killer is already in your space.

The general rule if the bad guy is in your space (classroom or office) is,

Run away from a knife.

Run toward a gun.

Unless you can outrun a bullet, your only salvation will be in closing with the bad guy to get underneath or beside his barrel, and get it pointed in a safe direction (usually up).

If you are out in the open, run perpendicular or at a forward angle, forcing the shooter to traverse if he or she wants to track you. 

If you are running away from a gun in a channelized space such as a hallway, try to zig-zag.

If you are in the open, with a short distance to your next cover, move fast and in a straight line.

We can try to avoid being in crowds, but sometimes that can’t be helped.

What we can do is not place crowds of vulnerable people where they will be exposed to threats, in places where their ability to move / escape will be restricted.

I’ve conduced site security surveys for two schools recently that had their rally points for fire drills in spots that were both hemmed in by fence and lower than the surrounding terrain, creating perfect area targets. Fencing around the rally point may keep kids from wandering off, but it will also keep them from dispersing should that area target be threatened.

Better yet, let’s make the rally point somewhere defensible. Recall that students and teachers in Jonesboro took shelter from the killers in the school gymnasium.

Westside Middle School in Jonesboro, from the basketball courts. Students and teachers coming out of the building on the left were gunned down where that slate colored awning is today (it was not there then). Some were able to take shelter in the gym, the larger building on the other side the memorial garden and its awning from the basketball courts.

Why not make the gym our go-to rally point, unless the gym itself is on fire–which almost never happens with modern school construction?

Gyms also have a limited number of exits, but if somebody’s gonna shoot at you in a hard-sided (brick or concrete sided) gymnasium, he’ll already be inside the gym, where you have half a chance at getting at him, not taking pot shots at the group of you from a hundred meters or more.

–George H, career security & public safety professional

Ps.–Here at home, as good guys, other answers to the question of “How far away can you hit something with your rifle?” might include “How far away can I identify if it is a threat?” and “Is the threat in the open, in front of a wall, or in a crowd?”

We are responsible for the final resting place of every bullet we launch; the bad guys are not similarly restricted.

Refer to ASR Rifles and ARS Med Kits for further information about when it’s appropriate–yea, verily, desirable–to defend at distance, when it might be better to just seek cover, and how a rifle can be a viable defensive tool.

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,